Showing posts with label Stotesbury. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stotesbury. Show all posts

18.12.09

Post Stotesbury Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.

A Novice blogger has many things to learn, and my lesson this morning is not to dive into large subjects too soon.  I'm exhausted from the three post tour of the Stotesbury's Down East hideaway and hope you all haven't run away in fear of my next house tour.  I'm about to re-read Strunk & White's Elements of Style, and will practice concision, concision, concision.  I promise, for your sake and mine, the next house tour is a five room gem way down east, and we'll get it neatly under our belts in one post

In the meanwhile, in case you haven't entirely tired of Mrs. Stotesbury, variously the mother-in-law of General MacArthur and Doris Duke, here she is skewered as Mrs. Dukesbury by the incomparable Margaret Dumont in the Marx Brothers 1938 romp At the Circus.


STOTESURY SUMMERS: Part 3: Inside Wingwood House




Mrs. Stotesbury and her emeralds in 1926, the year Wingwood was completed. Pastel portrait by Douglas Chandor

Note:  For Part 1, Click HERE

           For Part 2, Click HERE

A sense of the Stotesbury's simple summers by the sea can be gleaned from the 1946 Wingwood auction catalog, where table linens are listed by the mile, and silver flatware, dinner china, and crystal were listed by the hundreds and thousands of pieces.

Inside Wingwood House, the merry aesthetic confusion  of the exterior continued. The architects, Magziner, Eberhard, & Harris, were primarily theater architects, and the complex floorplan suffered from being the remodel of a very large house to an enormous house.

In an interview with James Maher, Mrs. Stotesbury's son, serial heiress husband James Cromwell (Delphine Dodge,  Doris Duke ), remembered that while Lord Duveen had supplied much of the art and furnishings, the interiors were the work Philadelphia decorator Gustav Ketterer in conjunction with Chapman, Inc., who had also worked on a restoration of Independence Hall. Interestingly, Lord Duveen did supply an eighteenth century French drawing room for Hauterive,  the neighboring Miles Carpenter estate just north of Wingwood.

 Mrs. Stotesbury, emeralds, playboy son
 Despite the building's strict symmetry, the main entrance was not in the center, where a false door was located, but in the North arcade that shielded the large service wing from the public areas.

(All interior photos by Mattie Edwards Hewitt, from Samuel Freeman Company auction catalog.)

 

One entered under the Porte Cochere with its roof copied from Mulberry Plantation, and from there  down  a long arcade, floored with Zenitherm, a material much beloved by designers in the jazz age.  There was a room in the service wing overlooking the driveway, staffed by the switchboard operator.  One of her tasks was to alert the butler when cars entered the gate, so he could already be opening the door as a chauffeur discharged  passengers under the porte cochere.  The four 18th century painted Gothick benches, redolent of Strawberry Hill, are enviable.

 
One would then turn right into the entrance hall (not pictured), then turn left into another long hall.  One would pass the North stairhall, with its scenic wallpaper and curving staircase.

 
Decorating the walls were handsome 18th century landscapes, with an 18th century Georgian marble fireplace ahead, surmounted by a self portrait by Vigee LeBrun.

After another right past the fireplace, and one went through the Cross Hall, past a small reception room (neither pictured), and into the Red Hall, with its 18th century English mantel and trumeau., and another gracefully curved staircase, in front of the false Nickels-Sortwell doorway centering the Garden facade

Why Red Hall, I don't know.  I once owned a pair of the columns salvaged from the demolition, as well as the sofa seen here.  The columns were painted a traditional Georgian green, and the sofa was upholstered in emerald green damask.
 
To the right was a large dining room, with English portraits purchased from Duveen.  The scale is deceptive.  Although the rooms look low, the ceiling heights were about 12 feet.

 
 
Across the Hall from the Dining Room was the Chippendale Drawing Room, with the finest of the house's English chimney pieces, and some very dated lampshades.

 
 Wingwood, the Green Drawing Room
 
 Four Acres/Wingwood House, the Cassatt's den, prior to its incarnation as the Green Drawing Room
(American Architect & Building News)
Turning back into the Red Hall, one could then head south through the Green Drawing Room, in the 18th century French style, with painted chinoiserie panels set into the boiserie, and the ubiquitous bust of Marie Antoinette on the 18th century marble mantel.  In the Cassatt era, this room had been the den, and it is amusing to compare the Cassatt's arts and crafts sensibilities to the Stotesbury's evocation of royalty past.

From the Green Drawing Room, one continued to the Garden Room, 60 feet long.  Borrowing design details from the dining room at Syon House in London, designed by Robert Adam, the version at Wingwood house was specially designed for the set of Adam furniture that furnished it.  The room was equipped with hidden speakers and a motion picture screen and projection booth, great luxuries for that pre blu-ray era.


 
From the garden room, one proceeded into the south arcade, which in turn led to the domed tearoom   By the time a guest arrived here for tea with Mrs. Stotesbury, one had traveled an indoor distance of over two hundred feet  from the front door in the opposite wing.

The tearoom opened to an enclosed 'colonial' garden designed by landscape architect Beatrix Farrand, designer of Dumbarton Oaks, who also had an estate at Bar Harbor. (UC Berkeley, Documents Department, Farrand Collection)
 
North Hall, second floor

 
Game Room, with Mr. Stotesbury's racing trophies

Two Views of Mrs. Stotesbury's Bedroom.  Her suite included a boudoir, dressing room, bath, and 'hideaway', with massage table.
The Apricot Guest Room
 
The second floor sitting room, opening to the curved portico on the ocean front.

The Colonial guestroom on the third floor.

The depression took its toll on even the Stotesbury fortune.  Mr. Stotesbury died in 1938, leaving a mere ten million---over a hundred million in today's inflated dollars---barely enough to run three palatial households.  Whitemarsh, the palace in Philadelphia, was shuttered and sold to a chemical company, Mrs. Stotesbury moved to Washington, and lived relatively quietly there and at Wingwood and El Mirasol, until her death in 1946. The forest fire of 1947 spared Wingwood, but burned its ten car garage across the street.  The contents of Wingwood were auctioned, the house was eventually sold to a Carolyn Trippe, who could not afford it. Abandoned and overgrown by 1952, it was purchased by the Canadian National Railroad, who intended to use the site for a terminal for their ferry service to Nova Scotia.  To appease the concerns of the town, the Canadian National originally said they intended to use Wingwood as the terminal and a hotel, but in 1953 changed their mind, issuing a statement that "no one is interested in maintaining these old palaces anymore" and Wingwood was demolished.  It was followed a few years later by it neighbor to the north, Hauterive, with its Duveen drawing room, and lacquered dining room by Baron DeMeyer; replaced by a motel.  A couple years later, the estate to the south, Sir Harry Oakes's The Willows, was converted to a motel, its sweeping lawns covered with lodging units.  The old Bar Harbor was gone.

The elaborate 80-room Wingwood produced a great deal of architectural salvage.  Several of its decorative components can be seen on houses around Mt. Desert Island.  A mantel showed up in a Christie's sale.  .  Over the years the trumeau from the red hall, a pair of columns and a sofa, the mantel from the Apricot guestroom have all passed through my hands, and other pieces keep turning up in the marketplace, even 50 years later.
Pilaster capitals from exterior of Wingwood

 As for Wingwood, this is  the site  today
Finis

17.12.09

STOTESBURY SUMMERS: Part 2: Identifying the Sources of Wingwood House

One of the intriguing aspects of the E.T. Stotesbury summer cottage in Bar Harbor,  also discussed in a previous post, is the giddy borrowing by Mrs. Stotesbury and her architects of details from famous New England houses of the Federal era.  Although the house was not itself a masterpiece, it was beautifully crafted, and individual details were often lovely, despite the awkwardness of scale and proportion between many elements.

Wingwood, detail of Garden  Room Wing, southeast corner
We know that Mrs. Stotesbury admired the Nickels-Sortwell House in Wiscassett, and a photograph of that house exists with notes by Mrs. Stotesbury about how much she admired its entrance, which would be cribbed for Wingwood. It is not a great leap to wonder if she ever consulted Fiske Kimball for ideas about great New England buildings for inspiration at Wingwood.  Well known to her as the director of the Philadelphia Museum of Art, Kimball was an expert about early American architecture, and would eventually publish the definitive book about Samuel McIntire, the Salem architect-carver whose buildings would be heavily mined for details for Wingwood.
The overall massing of Wingwood's garden front, with its wings forming a forecourt owes a great deal to Samuel McIntire's design for the Elias Hasket Derby mansin of 1795 in Salem, one of the grandest houses of Federalist America.
 Wingwood, west front facing Eden Street. (Mattie Edwards Hewitt, from Freeman Auction Company Catalog)

Samuel McIntire.  Design for Elias Hasket Derby Mansion, (Cousins, 'Woodcarver of Salem')
The main block featured a two story colonnade, with balustrade copied from a house in  Lost behind the portico, was another, a copy of the Nickels-Sortwell portico and Palladian Window.

Something was lost in the translation--the composition was fussed up with two poorly scaled arched  windows on either side of the door, and two oval bathroom windows flanking the upper Palladian window.  Further, the door was false,  fronting the circular staircase in the Red Hall beyond, and the small arched windows were actually the doors to the hall.

Wingwood, false door on garden facade (R), and prototype at Nickels-Sortwell House (L)

The two flanking wings, awkwardly scaled in relation to the main block, were blown up versions of McIntire's famous summer house for Elias Hasket Derby's country estate.  Much wider than their prototype, the wings lost in the translation, with pasted on facades that did not 'return' on the sides.
(L) Wingwood, Garden Wing; (R) Derby Summerhouse, 1797

Spreading out from the McIntire wings were two arcaded galleries, one an entrance corridor, the other a long passage to a tea room.  These also were based on a similar feature at the Derby mansion.

Finally, many leagues away from the Sortwell doorway, the arcade wings ended in two pavilions, one a porte cochére, the other a tea room opening into a 'colonial' formal garden designed by noted landscape architect Beatrix Farrand, a Bar Harbor neighbor.  The rusticated facades of these pavilions, inspired by pavilions in Sweden,  left the American neoclassical behind,  but in their roof design takes us on an unexpected detour to the early 18th century south, and the famous roofs on the flankers at Mulberry Plantation outside Charleston SC, a long way from Wiscassett, Maine.
Wingwood, detail drawing of porte cochére
Mulberry House, b. 1714, showing ogee roofs that inspired Wingwood (HABS)
Turning to the ocean front, one finds the window entablatures, and the side door from the Chippendale room are copies of details from houses near the Nickels House in Wiscassett, and of a pure Maine federal sensibility.  The McIntire summerhouse facades re-appear on  the wings.  A giant Palladian window in the ballroom wing has no early American precedent, but is borrowed from a London design of Robert Adam.
Finally, in the center of the main block, the giant curved portico, two recessed stories above a rusticated ovoid base, is directly based on both a similar feature in McIntire's Derby Mansion, and Charles Bulfinch's Joseph Barrell House in Charlestown, Massachusetts, later remodeled as the McLean asylum. Deterring from the composition is a wide fourth floor level dormer giving access to the portico roof.

Wingwood, Portico on ocean front
Charles Bulfinch.  Design for Joseph Barrell House, Charlestown, Massachusetts, showing semi-circular portico.
No doubt the decision to remodel the Cassatt cottage rather than build anew, combined with the mid-design change in architects and program, and Mrs. Stotesbury's general preference for grandeur, did not help the project.  It would probably have been better if the design had started from scratch. Nevertheless, Wingwood is an interesting footnote to an era and to it's owner's sensibilities.

Wingwood.  Vintage postcard view, 1930's.
I'll give you a couple of days to recover from this post, and finish up with a less talkative  tour of the interior, where the pictures speak for themselves, and we get to count the Stotesbury's silver flatware.

For Part 3 of this post, Click HERE

11.12.09

STOTESBURY SUMMERS, Part 1: The Stotesburys Build a Summer Cottage

In 1912 widowed banker E.T. Stotesbury, the senior partner of the Philadelphia office of the Morgan Bank, and one of the country's richest men, married the charming widow Lucretia Roberts Cromwell.


Hitherto a reserved and prudent man, whose greatest luxury was his fine stable, Mr. Stotesbury embarked on a spending spree with his new bride, building mansions and palaces from Bar Harbor to Palm Beach, buying Mrs. Stotesbury some world class jewelry, the yacht Nedeva, and entertaining non-stop.  After having Horace Trumbauer remodel his Philadelphia townhouse, Stotesbury then engaged Trumbauer to build Whitemarsh Hall in Springfield Township, PA, one of the largest and most lavish houses ever built in America.

 Whitemarsh Hall

Next, the Happiest Spendthrifts turned their eyes toward Palm Beach, where they commissioned Trumbauer to build an oceanfront palace.  At about the same time, wild man architect Addison Mizner electrified Palm Beach with the design of the new Everglades Club, in Spanish style.  Trumbauer was dismissed, and Mrs. Stotesbury hired Mizner to design a lavish Spanish villa, El Mirasol, which immediately became THE house in Palm Beach--until usurped by Marjorie Merriweather Post's Mar a Lago---but that's another story.

Courtyard of El Mirasol
By this time, the 20's were roaring in.  Already in possession of the grandest houses in Philadelphia and Palm Beach, Mrs. Stotesbury turned her attention to her summer housing. And here our story begins:

In the late 19th century, Bar Harbor, Maine, was considered second only to Newport as a Social resort.  Always considered the simpler, less showy counterpart, Bar Harbor never went in for Newport-style palace building.  But, by any other standard the hills and shores of Mt. Desert Island, where Bar Harbor is located, were littered with cottages that ranged in size from merely large to vast.  These cottages were built in most of the popular styles of the day--shingle cottages, Italian villas, Norman castles, Tudor manors and other styles too frightening to mention, designed by some of the leading architects of the day for some of the leading families of the day.

View of Bar Harbor Cottages from Bar Island, c. 1900
Mr. Stotesbury had summered in Bar Harbor for years, and owned Bar Island, just off-shore from town. He and Mrs. Stotesbury were comfortably ensconced in leased quarters, the Warner Leeds estate, Greenway Court out on the Ocean Drive.

Greenway Court, designed by Andrews, Jacques, & Rantoul, and leased by the Stotesburys before they purchased the Cassatt estate.
Comfortable though Greenway Court was, Mrs. Stotesbury had other ideas, and the couple purchased 'Four Acres', the estate of Mary Cassatt's brother Alexander, the late president of the Pennsylvania Railroad.  The Cassatt estate had been well designed 20 years earlier in an arts & crafts idiom by the Boston firm of Chapman & Frazer (architects, incidentally of George Bush's Kennebunkport summer home).  Finding it dark, dated, and unfashionable, Mrs. Stotesbury ordered a remodel, summoning the fashionable Palm Beach architect Howard Major, noted for his understated classical style.

Four Acres, the A.J. Cassatt cottage in Bar Harbor, as it appeared when the Stotesburys purchased it.
A vintage advertisement featuring Four Acres
Mrs. Stotesbury had fallen in love with the simple white clapboard colonial and Federal houses of New England, particularly the Nichols-Sortwell House in Wiscassett, and wished her Maine cottage to resemble them.
Be careful what you wish for.  Major's proposals were vaguely unsatisfying to Mrs. Stotesbury, and in the mid 1920's she was introduced to Louis Magaziner, of the firm Magaziner, Eberhard, & Harris, with the idea that he might be able to help resolve her design issues.  Supplied by Mrs. Stotesbury with books and postcards of the New England buildings she particularly admired, Mr. Magaziner, whose firm was hitherto best known for theatre design, went to work synthesizing her ideas and overlaying them on the footprint of the Cassatt house.
Architect's rendering of Wingwood House, formerly Four Acres, approximately the same view as above
Just as things were going well, Lord Duveen, the legendary English art dealer with a particular talent for parting Fricks, Huntingtons, Mellons, Wideners, and Stotesburys from their money, offered Mrs. Stotesbury a suite of Adam furniture from a ducal family.  Having no other place to put it, it was decided that the design for the 'big room' at the new Bar Harbor house should be enlarged to house the set.  With this change, the entire design, already under construction, had to be scaled up and reworked, and this is apparently the moment that things went out of control.
 The Nickels-Sortwell house on steroids--the central block of Wingwood House under construction.  Four Acres has sprouted a third floor, a neoclassical portico, and many large wings. The two center chimneys mark the same spot in the Cassatt House
When  finished in 1926, the Stotesbury cottage was a huge, slightly incoherent agglomeration of details borrowed from a dozen famous New England houses----an architectural compendium of greatest hits of the 1780's-1820's. albeit beautifully crafted with lovely individual details.  Over 1,000,000 pre-Depression dollars ($24,000,000 in today's money)  had been spent.  Full grown elm trees were found and uprooted from their original site, transported to Wingwood. Technology was up to the minute, with all the luxuries of the day---three furnaces to take off the chill on a foggy day by the shore, a 53 line house telephone system, 20-odd bathrooms, hidden motion picture projection equipment in the 60 foot ballroom, electric wall heaters for the bathrooms, a 38 room service wing built around a courtyard, and two elevators.  An article in Town & Country declared it to be the largest Colonial style house in America, a dubious title that probably belonged to Marion Davies Santa Monica Beach House. But let's not split hairs---there is no doubt that the Stotesbury's summer cottage, like their other houses, was Huge, and designed to Impress.

Whatever her exterior desires, the simple pleasures of colonial design were not for the imperial Mrs. Stotesbury's interiors.  In  the principle rooms, the giddy mix included an arcaded entrance gallery with gothick benches, a Louis XVI reception room that led from the Georgian hall to the Adamesque Garden (Ball) Room, and a Chinese Chippendale Drawing Room, all hiding behind the New England facade. There were 18 fireplaces, many sporting superb 18th English Marble chimney pieces.

More about Wingwood  in two future posts, in which we first examine the design sources of the exterior, and then go inside to 'ooh' and 'ahh' at the highly decorated interiors.

For Part 2 of Wingwood House, Click Here:
http://thedowneastdilettante.blogspot.com/2009/12/summer-delirium-colonial-style-part-2.html

And for Part 3, With Interior view, click here:
http://thedowneastdilettante.blogspot.com/2009/12/summer-delirium-colonial-style-part-3.html